Mon to Fri, 9am to 5pm (314) 891-0078
Menu
  1. Home
  2. What we buy
  3. Old coins

Selling old coins in St. Louis

Albums, flips, rolls and coffee cans. We grade raw coins ourselves, price certified coins on their holder grade and tell you plainly which pieces are common.

Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm, by appointment.

Rather we call you?

Leave your name and number and we will call you back the same business day.

Or call (314) 891-0078

Free and private. No obligation to sell.

Magnifying glass over coins in a plastic tray beside older silver coins on red velvet
Magnifying glass over coins in a plastic tray beside older silver coins on red velvet.

Coins we buy

  • Large cents and Indian Head cents
  • Wheat cents and two cent pieces
  • Shield, Liberty and Buffalo nickels
  • Barber, Mercury and Roosevelt silver dimes
  • Seated Liberty and Barber quarters and halves
  • Walking Liberty and Franklin halves
  • Proof sets and mint sets
  • PCGS and NGC graded coins

How we price old coins

Silver coins have a floor set by their silver. Dimes, quarters and halves dated through 1964 are 90 percent silver and always carry that value. Copper and nickel coins sit at face value or a little above unless the date or grade lifts them.

Above that floor, three things matter most: the date, the mint mark and the condition. We look at each candidate coin under magnification and price the better ones on their own lines.

Coins from St. Louis houses

St. Louis families handled a lot of cash. Brewery workers on Pestalozzi Street, shoe factory crews downtown, shopkeepers on the Hill and streetcar men all got paid in coin and bills for most of the last century. Many pulled the silver out of their change and kept it.

Those jars and folders are still in basements from Carondelet to Baden. Most of what is inside is common, but there is usually silver, and every so often a coin that deserves a second look.

Going through a coffee can

Most cans and jars that come to us in St. Louis look about the same once they are poured out. The bulk is copper: wheat cents from the 1940s and 1950s and Lincoln Memorial cents after that. Mixed in are nickels, a scattering of silver dimes and quarters, maybe a few halves and a coin or two nobody can name.

We split the pile by metal first. Then we go through the silver and the older copper for dates collectors want. Only after that does the silver go on the scale, and the rest gets counted.

Coins that earn a second look

No single date guarantees a windfall, but these always get checked closely.

  • Indian Head cents from 1877 and the S mint 1908 and 1909
  • Shield and Liberty nickels with full dates
  • Barber dimes, quarters and halves in better grades
  • Seated Liberty silver from before 1891
  • Standing Liberty quarters with a readable date
  • Mercury dimes from 1916-D and 1921
  • Two cent and three cent pieces from the 1860s

Mint marks in plain terms

A mint mark is a tiny letter showing where a coin was struck: D for Denver, S for San Francisco, O for New Orleans and CC for Carson City. Coins struck in Philadelphia usually have none. One date can be plentiful from one mint and hard to find from another.

Wheat cents carry the letter just below the date. On Mercury dimes it is on the back near the bottom. On Barber coins it is under the wreath on the reverse. We check every coin, so there is no need to sort them first.

Proof sets and mint sets

St. Louis families bought a lot of Mint sets over the years. Sets from 1964 and earlier have 90 percent silver coins, and silver proof sets from 1992 on carry silver too. Clad sets from 1968 to 1991 usually sell near face value. Leave them in their original packaging and we will price each group.

Keeping a few

Many sellers hold back a birth year set, a parent's favorite coin or a dollar given at a baptism. The written offer lists every coin or group, so you can choose. Pulling a few pieces out does not change the price on the rest.

Related reading: Raw vs graded coins: do you need coins graded to sell?

Old coins: questions

Do you buy coins that have never been graded?

Yes. Nearly every coin we buy is raw. We grade it ourselves at the table.

Are my wheat pennies worth anything?

Most are a few cents each. A few dates, like the 1909-S VDB, 1914-D and 1931-S, are worth far more, and we check for them.

Should I clean the coins first?

Please do not. Cleaning lowers the price. Bring them as they are.

Find out what your coins and old money are worth

Call for a free private appraisal anywhere in the St. Louis area. Every coin, bill and piece of gold is checked where you can watch, and the offer is written down.

Call (314) 891-0078 Request a written offer online Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. No obligation to sell.
Call (314) 891-0078